Appointment of a CEO and a Chief Accountant National Assets can make India Tax free and Debt free country by 2029
Open Letter to legendary
Prime Minister of India
Respected Sir,
You are a specially gifted blessed pious soul and a selfless
Karmyogi. What you have given to people of India in last 20 years as Chief
Minister of Gujarat and in your first term as Prime Minister of India has
already turned the table. The country is no more a Loot Raj, it has been
transformed in to a Welfare State. You have proved to be a Messiah for the down
trodden who could have never ever imagined possession of a Toilet block in
house, Gas, Electric, a Pucca House, good education for their children, costly
treatment for the poor and many - many things more. Through your Statesmanship
and implementation of a Win-Win-Win policy of ‘Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas’ in
letter and spirit, India has established friendly relations throughout the
world even with adversary countries and established its leadership. The enemies
within and without are learning a lesson and have realized ‘Ab Aur Nahi
Chalega’. People of India have recognized your service and spirit for them and
have rewarded you for it. Your landslide victory is a testimony to that. Please
continue with it in your second stint but sir you are made for much more.
Sir, in your second stint as Prime Minister you can now give
such an unimaginable gift to humanity that shall make you immortal; you shall
always be remembered in history. And that GIFT is freeing everybody from the agony
of parting with virtually half of their hard earned income in taxes and the tyranny
of tax regime – a totally Tax-free arena. It shall be ‘MODINOMICS’
replacing the 90 year old Keynesian theory. Sir, the backbone of the Modinomics is your own
theory ‘Government has no Business to be in Business’. As a CEO I can
clearly see that if this theory is implemented in letter and spirit the
government can generate so much revenue from its Assets that there shall be no
need to extract tax money from the people. And ‘Abki Baar Tax Free Sarkar’ can
easily be your genuine offer for 2024 to people of India and that shall set a
yard stick for the entire world to achieve.
Taxes are the biggest charge and agony in everybody’s
life – be he the rich or the poor. I can’t forget the pain I saw in the eyes of
my Doctor when she bursted and exclaimed that ‘look, Agarwalji, we earn just 1%
as Incentive after working from morning till night and even from that meager amount
GST is deducted’! As for rich, tax is
the hottest subject for discussion in all their gatherings and thousands are
losing sleep over some amount they deposited offshore to save some tax amount.
In Tax free economy there shall be no black money – all
money will be White and Glittering because money is same, it becomes Black only
if tax is not paid on it. No requirement of tax payment, so no tyrannical agencies
like ED, CBI, Income Tax Department etc.
Sir, you have
promised doubling farmer’s income by 2022. By removing taxes you shall double EVERYONE’s
income on its implementation and that shall be equal to or more than depositing
money in everyone’s bank account. In a Tax-free regime capital shall pour in
India from its own citizens who have stashed it overseas as well as from entrepreneurs
of the world. India already has plenty
of natural resources, people friendly climate and a bountiful of intelligent
man- power. What it needs for growth is Capital. With capital flowing in to India from all
corners of world India shall become center of world’s manufacturing and its supply
hub.
Sir, I do not claim any expertise for achieving this noble
goal. You have a huge think tank of intellectuals who can chart a clear
implementable Road map for it. I am only being a Thought Provoker in this
direction and as a CEO I explain below an action plan for it.
Your vision of ‘Government has no Business to be in
Business’ means that existing commercial ventures of Government are to be charted
out to Private Sector. Government should receive a commensurate income from
them regularly to meet its operating cost. To this I add one more very valuable
important factor – income from all kinds
of national assets the value of which is not even known what to say earning
from them. I have already given you an example of it in my letter dated
11.6.2019 about huge earning potential from Forests and I shall present earning
potential of all other Ministries one by one in coming period.
Government has a huge stock of various kinds of assets
which are not generating due revenue and are being abused by unscrupulous
people in connivance with or without government officials like illegal mining. Either
the Government is not aware of it or turning a blind eye. So much so this
important source of revenue is never discussed in budget presentation. Presently
a meager amount in the range of Rs 2 to 3 lakh crore is being earned from
national assets. Ignominiously
it is termed as ‘Non-Tax Revenue’ in the Budget.
Income from National Assets called Non-tax revenue in
last three years -
|
2017-2018
वास्तविक Actuals |
2018-2019
बजट अनुमान Budget Estimates |
2018-2019
संशोधित अनुमान Revised Estimates |
2019-2020
बजट अनुमान Budget Estimates |
1.Gross Tax Revenue
|
1919009
|
2271242
|
2248175
|
2552131
|
2.Non-Tax Revenue comprising of:
|
192744
|
245089
|
245276
|
272647
|
a) Interest
receipts
|
13574
|
15162
|
12047
|
12911
|
b) Dividends and Profits
|
91360
|
107312
|
119265
|
136071
|
b) External
Grants
|
3582
|
2667
|
1270
|
1006
|
d) Other Non
Tax Revenue*
|
82338
|
117886
|
110619
|
120509
|
e) Receipts
of Union Territories
|
1890
|
2062
|
2076
|
2149
|
*Other non- tax
revenue include recovery from disinvestment which really means from selling
house silver itself and not income from it.
My research says this amount can be multiplied many
times. This I say after studying earning potential of our various Ministries.
In my second letter to you sir, dated 11 June 2019 I have given you my study
about Ministry of Forest. The study shows Forest Ministry, presently depending
on tax revenue, can in fact earn a huge income not only to meet its own
operational cost but provide a good quantum of support to the budget.
Sir, to bring such transformation two new Positions shall
have to be created and filled up with most competent persons. These are-
First and foremost is appointment
of a top of the line CEO from commercial arena. CEOs are a different class of
people. They are trained to EARN commensurate income from the Resources given
to them like a Project. They have a different mindset. Their job cannot be
performed by Administrative experts or even Economists. You have personal rapport with most of the
top CEOs of India and of the world and that shall come handy to select a proper
competent result oriented person. Their job profile and quality is explained in
Annexure ‘A’.
Secondly, a very competent
Chartered Accountant shall need to be appointed. He shall enlist, evaluate and prepare
a Balance Sheet of all Assets and Liabilities of the country. His role profile
and methodology is explained in Annexure ‘B’
Sir, give it a serious thought. The country is missing a
great wealth creating opportunity. Government shall get a huge amount of income
from its Assets and people shall not have to part with their hard earned income
by way of taxes.
Sir क्योंकि आप हैं तो मुमकिन है।
Job Profile of the CEO – Chief Executive Officer - National Assets
Ø The
position of CEO National Assets is conceived to be similar to National Security
Advisor (NSA). He shall enjoy the status of a Cabinet Minister. He shall report
directly to the Prime Minister. He may be designated as NAA –National Assets
Advisor or similar.
Ø The
CEO shall be tasked to generate optimum revenue from the national assets and
resources.
Ø His
responsibilities shall include -
Ø Make
PM’s philosophy of ‘Government has no business to be in business’ a
success in all possible ways like Reengineering all new development plans in a
manner that they are executed by private sector while government earns a
regular income from them in the form of equity, lease rent, interest, etc.
Ø Making
attractive business plans and attract the private sector from whole world to
take over existing government enterprises – profit making, as well as loss
making in a manner that government earns regular income from them.
Ø Enlisting
and monetizing all national assets. Countries world over do not have a stock list
of all national assets and value thereof. I have been able to develop a
Methodology for it for the first time in world. It is briefly outlined in
Annexure ‘B’. Detailed Methodology shall be provided to Government on their
asking.
Ø The
NAA shall be responsible to look after growth, safety, accounting, security,
proper administration, generation of commensurate revenue from all existing and
new National Assets belonging to every Ministry of Union Government as well as of
all States of India.
Ø The NAA
shall be provided services of a ‘National Chief Accountant Assets’, who
shall be a Chartered Accountant and whose role profile is described in Annexure
‘B’ for proper accounting of National Assets.
Ø The NAA shall study what Goods and Services
are produced by all Ministries of the National and State Governments and a
prepare plan to generate commensurate revenue from them. His objective shall be
to make every Ministry self supporting to meet its operating cost and
development plans and stop using tax money.
Even for Defence Ministry and Home Ministry he shall study what assets
the Ministries possesses that can generate revenue. The effort shall be that
every Ministry not only meets its own revenue needs but also contributes to
exchequer to pay off national debt.
Ø The
country should come out of Deficit Financing rut and produce Surplus every
year.
Ø The
NAA shall do financial engineering of new projects in a manner that private
sector executes them with their own finances but Central Government gains
permanent income from such assets by way of Equity and Lease Rent etc.
Qualities of a CEO that differentiates him from others
The CEO is all the time 365 x 24/7, is under pressure to
EARN and give commensurate return on the value of resources provided to him.
Not only that, the return should increase every subsequent year. The moment his
earning starts stagnating he is removed. A CEO’s job is most unsecured job.
Annexure ‘B’
Chief Accountant National Assets,
Job Profile of the Chief Accountant National
Assets (CAA)
The CAA shall be a highly experienced Chartered
Accountant with deep experience of making Balance Sheets of large Corporations
having several affiliates (and not from Taxation side). He shall report to the NAA.
He shall compute and present following
reports :-
ü An
exhaustive list of all National Assets both in Public and Private domain in
quantity and value location wise every year.
ü Annual
Balance Sheets of every State and Union of India enlisting all their assets and
liabilities in the standard format of Balance Sheet as prescribed by Company
Law Board for listed enterprises.
ü Shall
present financial profile of every Ministry of Union Government and State
Governments giving full detail of all assets possessed by them..
ü Financial profile of every village, town, city
& Metro enlisting and evaluating their all assets and civic amenities
The research made by me shall enable preparing all these
critical and revealing reports. I have made a thorough research in working of
Government during last several years and have compiled a Research paper that
runs in to some 500 pages. I call my research ‘Monetizing Nations’. Basic fundamentals
of this research are given below. Full research paper can be presented to the
Government on their asking.
All the above data shall be uploaded on a website and
shall be available for public viewing at all times.
In my research I found that government has a very
systematic data base on all subjects.
All revenue and expenditure is well recorded. The country has been
subdivided in to well-defined Geographical Entities. Detailed information
including area maps, geographical attributes, history, geographical features,
Administrators, natural resources and national assets, civic amenities,
economic activities, is available for every Geographical Entity in the DCHB
brought out by Census of India every teen years. There are 6.58 lakh
geographical entities in the country from big to small as per 2011 census.
However, there are no documents or reports that give financial value of these
assets.
On financial
matters I found country produces annual budget that gives account of revenue
received, where it was spent in past two years and what is the estimated
revenue and expenditure plan for the ensuing year. The country also produces a
GDP statement that gives monetary value of all goods and services produced in
the country – both in government and private sector. The data provided is
authentic, reliable and unbiased.
However, I was perplexed to find that the government does
not produce a Balance Sheet which is a statement of All Assets and Liabilities
of the enterprise. In business environment it is unthinkable to operate an
enterprise without this document. In
fact, Government of India has prescribed a standard format of Balance Sheet for
commercial enterprises but Government itself does not produce one.
On deeper study I
found that governments world over have not been able to produce this
document due to various complexities
like-
1. The
country is spread over a vast area – India is spread over 32.86 lakh Sq km,
having various kinds of features - like vast cities to small hamlets,
mountains, hills, ravines, rivers, water bodies, forests, sea coast, etc.
2. The
country is bestowed with a rich bank of natural resources like land, water,
air, sunlight, airwaves, minerals, human resources, wild life, flora and fauna,
forests etc that have not been valued per unit of quantity.
It appears these impediments have deterred countries to
produce national balance sheet. On deep
study of data available and on the strength of my lifetime experience I have been able
to devise a methodology that shall enable systematic production of –
i)
Comprehensive Profile Statements of every
geographical entity enlisting all vital features of the entity and value of
various kinds of assets and resources available therein, both in public and
private domain, in quantity that can be converted in to money terms by
multiplying with unit cost of the asset.
ii)
Balance sheet of every State of India,
Central Government and a consolidated Balance Sheet of the nation as a whole.
iii)
This document shall be published annually. It
shall be on internet to be available globally to everyone who have need and can
benefit from this information.
iv)
This information shall open up flood gates
for qualitative and quantitative development of every geographical entity of
the country. In fact, and most importantly, while India resides in its urban
area spread over just 3% of its land area with only 30% population, Bharat
resides in 97% of the land area and nourishes 70% of its population.
v)
This 70% population contributes only about
17% to its GDP while 30% urban population enjoys major chunk of 83% of GDP. Thus
rural India is perennially poor and shall continue to remain so unless some
revolutionary steps are taken.
vi)
The Comprehensive Profile Statements for each
of these villages shall make available vital data that shall enable Planners,
its residents and all stake holders to think how their income can be increased
making full utilization of valuable natural resources and assets existing
there.
vii)
Annual Balance Sheets shall establish credit
worthiness of States of India and the country as a whole. An authentic Assets
report shall enable them to raise
capital for growth and development. India is short of capital only while other
factors of production - men and material are available in plenty and at
economical cost. .
Balance Sheet presents in an
authentic manner real Net Worth of an Enterprise. Lenders rely on this document for lending
money to an enterprise. All countries run on loans – huge loans.
National Balance Sheet shall
demonstrate real Strength of the country. Balance Sheet is not a luxury - it is
a must that serves various purposes including for Planning and for obtaining
loans.
Moreover, In order to
achieve the national goal of doubling farmers’ income in 2022 it is rather
essential that there is better utilization of natural resources and creation of
more productive assets in the villages.
For that these Comprehensive Profile Statements of every village listing
all of their natural resources and assets shall be extremely useful.
The Methodology explained here
is developed taking India as a model nation but employing same methodology
every country can be monetized especially because all countries maintain their
account as per the ‘Standard Accounting Procedure’ prescribed by United Nations
by and large. India is one of the largest economies of world and methodology
perfected on its basis can be safely applied to any country with minor
modifications.
National Assets and
Resources are listed below -
S.
No.
|
Asset
|
Constituents
|
1
|
Natural
Resources
|
Land, Forest,
Mountains, Rivers, Sea, Water bodies, Air, Sun, Wind, Minerals, Livestock,
birds and bees
|
2
|
Human
Resources
|
Farmers,
Skilled, Semi-skilled, unskilled labor, Businessmen, Industrialists,
Executives, Judiciary, Politicians, children, senior citizens including
males, females, etc
|
3
|
Infrastructure
|
Rail, Road,
Air, water, Power, Education, Health, Garbage collection & disposal, STPs
, etc
|
4
|
Agriculture
|
Farms,
Irrigation, Borewells, Livestock
|
5
|
Mines &
quarrying
|
Minerals,
Oil, Gas
|
6
|
Manufacturing
|
Large, Medium
& Small Private Factories and Enterprises (MSMEs), Public sector
Undertakings,
|
7
|
Services sector
|
Trading, Hospitality, Banking, Insurance, I.T. Professionals,
Storage, Tourism
|
8
|
Civic Amenities
|
Lighting
and power, Roads, Hospitals, Markets, Parks, Places of Tourist Interest,
etc
|
9
|
Real
Estate
|
Residential,
Commercial, Malls, Administrative buildings, Storage godowns, Textile, Food,
Defence & various other kind of
Parks
|
10
|
Public
Administration
|
Government
offices, Legislature, Courts, Police Stations, Embassies of foreign
countries, Research Institutions, Space Exploration , Internal Security
Agencies,
|
11
|
Armed
Forces ***
|
Army,
Air force, Navy, BSF,
|
12
|
Financial
Assets
|
Cash,
Bank Deposits, Gold, Silver and Diamonds, Foreign Currency, Loans, Advances,
Inventories, Shares of Corporates, Government Securities, etc
|
13
|
Intellectual
Properties
|
Music
and Films, Literature, Manufacturing process and designs, Space and other
research data
|
Present Financial Reports
In absence of Balance Sheet at present Governments world
over depend up on two financial documents – GDP and National Budget – their
contents and properties are explained herein after -
GDP and its Limitation
Gross domestic
product (GDP)
is a monetary measure of the market value of all the final
goods and services produced in a period
(quarterly or yearly) of time in the country. Nominal GDP estimates are
commonly used to determine the economic performance of a whole country or
region, and to make international comparisons.
Definition
The OECD defines
GDP as "an aggregate measure of production equal to the sum of
the gross values added of all resident and institutional units
engaged in production (plus any taxes, and minus any subsidies, on products not
included in the value of their outputs)”.
An IMF publication
states that "GDP measures the monetary value of final goods and
services—that are bought by the final user—produced in a country in a given
period of time (say a quarter or a year).
Total GDP can
also be broken down into the contribution of each industry or sector of the
economy. The ratio of GDP to the total population of the region is the per
capita GDP and the same is called Mean Standard of Living. At present GDP
is considered the "world's most powerful statistical indicator of national
development and progress".
History
The modern concept of GDP was first developed by Simon Kuznets for a US
Congress report in 1934. In this
report, Kuznets warned against its use as a measure of welfare. After the Bretton
Woods conference in 1944, GDP became the main
tool for measuring a country's economy. At that time Gross
National Product (GNP) was the preferred estimate, which differed from GDP in
that it measured production by a country's citizens at home and abroad rather
than its 'resident institutional units'. The switch from "GNP" to
"GDP" in the US was in 1991, trailing behind most other nations. The
role that measurements of GDP played in World War II was crucial to the
subsequent political acceptance of GDP values as indicators of national
development and progress. A crucial role was played here by
the US Department of Commerce under
Milton Gilbert where ideas from Kuznets were embedded into governmental
institutions.
Determining gross
domestic product (GDP)
GDP can be determined in three ways, all of which should, in
principle, give the same result. They are the Production (or
output or value added) approach, the Income approach, or the
speculated Expenditure approach.
The most direct of the three is the production approach, which
sums the outputs of every class of enterprise to arrive at the total. The
expenditure approach works on the principle that all of the product must be
bought by somebody, therefore the value of the total product must be equal to
people's total expenditures in buying things. The income approach works on the
principle that the incomes of the productive factors ("producers,"
colloquially) must be equal to the value of their product, and determines GDP
by finding the sum of all producers' incomes.
Limitation of GDP - Does High GDP Mean
Economic Prosperity?
How GDP Misses the Mark
From the perspective of a citizen living with the
day-to-day realities of life, GDP can be rather misleading.
GDP can increase after a car accident or a major flood.
GDP can grow rapidly during a war or after a terrorist attack. If all of a city
caught fire once again and burnt to the ground, the rebuilding effort just
might boost GDP. This is because GDP is very susceptible to the broken window
fallacy — false signals of rising prosperity when obvious destruction has taken
place.
Service of consumer durables and
infrastructure –
Money spent on durable goods is treated as a cost, while
the value the purchases provide is treated as a benefit. Long-lasting goods
that provide benefits without having to be frequently repurchased are viewed
positively. Goods that wear out quickly and drain consumers' wallets when they
must be replaced are viewed negatively. GDP, on the other hand, views all
expenditures as good news. Infrastructure spending by the government is treated
similarly: If spending provides a long-lasting benefit, GDP views it as a
positive but if spending drains the government's coffers it should be viewed
negative; GPI views it as a negative. Again, GDP views all spending as
positive. If the U.S. government spends $2 billion developing a new jet
warplane that never lifts off the ground, GDP treats that the same as a hospital
delivering $2 billion of cheap medicine or a tech entrepreneur sells $2 billion
worth of new software.
Crime - Rising crime costs
money in legal fees, medical bills, replacement costs and other outlays. GDP
views this spending as a positive development. GPI views it as a negative.
Ministry Releasing GDP data in India –
The Ministry of Statistics and
Programme Implementation releases GDP data in India.
A specimen report of India’s GDP
Sector
|
GVA (Rupees in Crore) at 2011-12 prices
|
GVA (Rupees in Crore) at current prices
|
|||
2016-17
|
% share
|
2016-17
|
% share
|
||
1
|
Agriculture
Sector
|
1,716,746
|
15.26
|
2,484,005
|
17.95
|
1.1
|
Agriculture,
forestry & fishing
|
1,716,746
|
15.26
|
2,484,005
|
17.95
|
1.11
|
Crops
|
1,033,008
|
9.18
|
1,530,137
|
11.05
|
1.12
|
Livestock
|
448,964
|
3.99
|
639,912
|
4.62
|
1.13
|
Forestry
& logging
|
138,779
|
1.23
|
180,465
|
1.30
|
1.14
|
Fishing
and aquaculture
|
95,996
|
0.85
|
133,492
|
0.96
|
2
|
Industry
Sector
|
3,542,821
|
31.50
|
4,054,112
|
29.29
|
2.1
|
Mining
& quarrying
|
371,066
|
3.30
|
332,947
|
2.41
|
2.2
|
Manufacturing
|
2,048,711
|
18.21
|
2,329,220
|
16.83
|
2.21
|
Food
Products, Beverages and Tobacco
|
174,619
|
1.55
|
212,347
|
1.53
|
2.22
|
Textiles,
Apparel and Leather Products
|
274,256
|
2.44
|
315,236
|
2.28
|
2.23
|
Metal
Products
|
263,186
|
2.34
|
251,748
|
1.82
|
2.24
|
Machinery
and Equipment
|
442,382
|
3.93
|
548,807
|
3.96
|
2.25
|
Other
Manufactured Goods
|
894,267
|
7.95
|
1,001,081
|
7.23
|
2.3
|
Electricity,
gas, water supply & other utility services
|
244,934
|
2.18
|
363,482
|
2.63
|
2.4
|
Construction
|
878,110
|
7.81
|
1,028,463
|
7.43
|
3
|
Services
Sector
|
5,988,062
|
53.24
|
7,303,474
|
52.76
|
3.1
|
Trade,
repair, hotels and restaurants
|
1,370,909
|
12.19
|
1,586,238
|
11.46
|
3.11
|
Trade
& repair services
|
1,250,502
|
11.12
|
1,446,832
|
10.45
|
3.12
|
Hotels
& restaurants
|
120,407
|
1.07
|
139,406
|
1.01
|
3.2
|
Transport,
storage, communication & services related to broadcasting
|
766,193
|
6.81
|
935,575
|
6.76
|
3.21
|
Railways
|
84,594
|
0.75
|
106,582
|
0.77
|
3.22
|
Road
transport
|
362,077
|
3.22
|
434,588
|
3.14
|
3.23
|
Water
transport
|
8,578
|
0.08
|
6,848
|
0.05
|
3.24
|
Air
transport
|
7,184
|
0.06
|
20,655
|
0.15
|
3.25
|
Services
incidental to transport
|
86,617
|
0.77
|
103,496
|
0.75
|
3.26
|
Storage
|
5,869
|
0.05
|
6,888
|
0.05
|
3.27
|
Communication
& services related to broadcasting
|
211,274
|
1.88
|
256,518
|
1.85
|
3.3
|
Financial,
real estate & prof servs
|
2,437,857
|
21.67
|
2,857,322
|
20.64
|
3.31
|
Financial
services
|
682,553
|
6.07
|
742,936
|
5.37
|
3.32
|
Real estate,
ownership of dwelling & professional services
|
1,755,304
|
15.61
|
2,114,386
|
15.28
|
3.4
|
Community,
social & pers. Servs
|
1,413,103
|
12.56
|
1,924,339
|
13.90
|
3.41
|
Public
administration & defence
|
637,056
|
5.66
|
859,615
|
6.21
|
3.42
|
Other
services
|
776,047
|
6.90
|
1,064,724
|
7.69
|
GVA at basic prices
|
11,247,629
|
13,841,591
|
The above report does not reflect monetary value of all kinds of
assets that have produced these goods and services.
National Budget – a statement of Revenue and Expenditure
Budget is an estimate of Income and Expenditure for
a set period of time.
A national budget is the budget of a country. The government gets
money from various sources like taxes and fees, Interest on loans given, rent
from its assets. It also borrows money, again from various sources. The
government spends these funds for various purposes which are divided in to two
main categories – Revenue Expenditure and Capital
Expenditure. Revenue Expenditure
include expenditure on heads like salaries and other costs of government
employees, welfare of its people on things like national defense,
infrastructure, grants for research, education, and the arts, and social
programs such as Social Security and Medicare and also to pay interest on money
it has borrowed for various purposes.
Capital expenditure is
incurred to create long term assets like infrastructure.
A National budget is
an annual financial statement that presents the government's expected revenues and proposed
spending for the ensuing financial year. The
National Budget is prepared by the Finance Minister. After approval by the
President the budget is presented to the Legislature for their consideration.
After passing by the legislature, with
or without amendment, the Budget is finally approved by the Chief
Executive or President. Then all expenses of
the nation are incurred within the amount sanctioned under various heads for
each Ministry. Similar exercise is carried out by each State of the country.
The budget is also known as the
Annual Financial Statement of the country. This document estimates the
anticipated government revenues and government expenditures for the ensuing
financial year.
Specimen of a National Budget…
Government of India
BUDGET AT A GLANCE for the Financial Year
2018-19
(In Rs. crore)
|
|||||
2016-2017
|
2017-2018
|
2017-2018
|
2018-2019
|
||
Actuals
|
Budget
|
Revised
|
Budget
|
||
Estimates
|
Estimates
|
Estimates
|
|||
1
|
Revenue Receipts
|
1374203
|
1515771
|
1505428
|
1725738
|
2. Tax Revenue
|
1101372
|
1227014
|
1269454
|
1480649
|
|
(Net to Centre)
|
|||||
3. Non-Tax Revenue
|
272831
|
288757
|
235974
|
245089
|
|
4
|
Capital Receipts1
|
600991
|
630964
|
712322
|
716475
|
5. Recovery of Loans
|
17630
|
11933
|
17473
|
12199
|
|
6. Other Receipts
|
47743
|
72500
|
100000
|
80000
|
|
7. Borrowings and
Other
|
|||||
Liabilitites2
|
535618
|
546531
|
594849
|
624276
|
|
8
|
Total Receipts (1+4)
|
1975194
|
2146735
|
2217750
|
2442213
|
9
|
Total Expenditure
(10+13)
|
1975194
|
2146735
|
2217750
|
2442213
|
10
|
On Revenue Account
|
||||
of which
|
1690584
|
1836934
|
1944305
|
2141772
|
|
11
|
Interest Payments
|
480714
|
523078
|
530843
|
575795
|
12
|
Grants in Aid for creation
|
||||
of capital assets
|
165733
|
195350
|
189245
|
195345
|
|
13
|
On Capital Account
|
284610
|
309801
|
273445
|
300441
|
14
|
Revenue Deficit (10-1)
|
316381
|
321163
|
438877
|
416034
|
-2.1
|
-1.9
|
-2.6
|
-2.2
|
||
15
|
Effective Revenue
Deficit (14-12)
|
150648
|
125813
|
249632
|
220689
|
-1
|
-0.7
|
-1.5
|
-1.2
|
||
16
|
Fiscal Deficit
[9-(1+5+6)]
|
535618
|
546531
|
594849
|
624276
|
-3.5
|
-3.2
|
-3.5
|
-3.3
|
||
17
|
Primary Deficit (16-11)
|
54904
|
23453
|
64006
|
48481
|
-0.4
|
-0.1
|
-0.4
|
-0.3
|
The Budget also does not give
financial value of all Assets of the country.
Balance Sheet and its multifarious advantages
Definition: Balance Sheet is the financial statement of a Company or an
Enterprise which includes assets, liabilities, equity capital, total debt, etc.
at a point in time. Balance Sheet includes assets on one side, and liabilities
on the other. For the Balance Sheet to reflect the true picture, both heads
(liabilities & assets) should tally (Assets = Liabilities +
Equity). The Balance Sheet gives values for two years – the year last
ended and the year before that. Thus it enables the viewer to judge whether the
enterprise has grown in the year last ended in comparison to the year before
that or lost.
In financial
accounting, a Balance Sheet or statement of financial
position is a summary of the financial balances of an individual or
organization, whether it is a sole proprietorship, a business
partnership, a corporation, private limited company or other
organization such as Government or not-for-profit
entity. Assets, liabilities and ownership equity are
listed as of a specific date, such as the end of its financial year. A
Balance Sheet is often described as a "snapshot of a company's
financial condition". Of the four basic financial
statements, the Balance Sheet is the only statement which applies to a single
point in time of a business' calendar year.
A standard company Balance Sheet has two
sides: assets, on the left and financing, which
itself has two parts, liabilities and ownership equity, on the right. (In modern current format of Balance Sheet Assets and
Liabilities are listed vertically, first Liabilities followed by Assets).
The main
categories of assets are usually listed first, and typically in order
of liquidity. Assets are followed by the liabilities. The difference
between the assets and the liabilities is known as Equity or the Net Assets or
the Net Worth or Capital of the company and according to
the accounting equation, Net Worth must equal assets minus liabilities.
Another way to
look at the Balance Sheet equation is that total assets equal liabilities plus
owner's equity. Looking at the equation in this way shows how assets were
financed: how much by borrowing money (liability) and how much by using the
owner's money (owner's or shareholders' equity). Balance Sheets are usually
presented with assets in one section and liabilities and net worth in the other
section with the two sections "balancing".
Balance Sheet
is the indicator of Company profile.
All good Corporates take great pain in
presenting their Balance Sheet. They make it a powerful and impressive showcase
of all that they have achieved not only in the year gone by but right from
their inception. They also present their growth plans for the current year and
coming years. The strength of the Corporation is demonstrated by giving various
ratios.
The Balance Sheet is a virtual mirror of
the Organization. All critical facts and data are presented in a manner that
all stake holders of the Organization get a realistic view of the factors of
their interest, like for their customers, suppliers, financiers, Government
organizations, Share holders, employees and for the talent they want to attract
in to their organization. A normal Balance Sheet comprises of some 170 – 200
pages tastefully presented with attractive charts, graphs, pictures, photos of
all Top Management, their Factories, important production machines etc.
Before the computer era printed copy of
Balance Sheet was sent to every share holder who ran in to thousands as well as
to all stake holders. In the present Computer age the Balance Sheet is uploaded
on the website and can be freely downloaded by anybody even if doing no
business with the Organization.
Specimen of a Balance Sheet
Statutory Format of Balance Sheet as
prescribed by Company Law Board
Consolidated Balance Sheet - Republic of
India
As At xx xx xxxx Rupees in
Crores
Particulars
|
Note no
|
Figures as at the end of current
reporting period
|
Figures as at the end of the previous
reporting period
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
I. EQUITY AND LIABILITIES
|
|
|
|
(1) Shareholders’ funds
|
|
|
|
(a) Nature’s gift
|
1
|
|
|
(b) Inherited at Independence
|
2
|
|
|
(c) Assets created since Independence
|
3
|
|
|
(2) Other
|
4
|
|
|
(3) Non-current liabilities
|
5
|
|
|
(a) Long-term borrowings
|
6
|
|
|
(b)
|
7
|
|
|
(c) Other Long term liabilities
|
8
|
|
|
(d) Long-term provisions
|
9
|
|
|
(4) Current liabilities
|
10
|
|
|
(a) Short-term borrowings
|
11
|
|
|
["(b) Trade Payables:-
(A) total outstanding dues of micro
enterprises and small enterprises; and
(B) total outstanding dues of
creditors other than micro enterprises and small enterprises.".]
|
12, 13,14
|
|
|
(c) Other current liabilities
|
15
|
|
|
(d) Short-term provisions
|
16
|
|
|
TOTAL
|
|
|
|
II. ASSETS
|
|
|
|
Non-current assets
|
17
|
|
|
(1) (a) Fixed assets
|
18
|
|
|
(i) Tangible assets
|
19
|
|
|
(ii) Intangible assets
|
20
|
|
|
(iii) Capital work-in-progress
|
21
|
|
|
(iv) Intangible assets under
development
|
22
|
|
|
(b) Non-current investments
|
23
|
|
|
(c) Deferred tax assets (net)
|
24
|
|
|
(d) Long-term loans and advances
|
25
|
|
|
(e) Other non-current assets
|
26
|
|
|
(2) Current assets
|
27
|
|
|
(a) Current investments
|
28
|
|
|
(b) Inventories
|
29
|
|
|
(c) Trade receivables
|
30
|
|
|
(d) Cash and cash equivalents
|
31
|
|
|
(e) Short-term loans and advances
|
32
|
|
|
(f) Other current assets
|
33
|
|
|
TOTAL
|
Game changing advantages of a National Balance Sheet
“We manage what we
measure.” is the popular adage.
·
Balance Sheet provides most important
information about an enterprise – what is its Net Worth! Net
worth is the difference between value of Assets and total liability. If after
setting off amount of all liabilities there remains a surplus then the Net
Worth is called Positive but if Liabilities outweigh Assets then Net Worth is
Negative. Net Worth of a sound economy shall always be positive and higher the
ratio of assets than liabilities stronger it is.
·
Moreover, in the Balance Sheet data is given
for two years. That denotes progress or retard in the year just ended over the
previous year. Thus it is the eyes of the entrepreneur and tells him he is
growing or he is losing. Purpose of every enterprise is to grow. The Balance
Sheet is the most authentic indicator of its performance and a tool to monitor
its growth.
·
Another big advantage of a Balance Sheet is
that it displays value of all assets of the enterprise in money terms. Value in
money terms is easily measurable and can be compared with various criteria than
in terms of quantity. For example, India has some 131,326 km length of
National Highways. If valued at an average construction cost of Rs. 10crore per
km, their value would be a humangous amount of Rs. 13,13,260 crores. Thus
information in money terms gives a better understanding.
·
Regular presentation of National Balance
Sheet shall put a check on massive corruption in selling, leasing, and
disposing of national resources and assets. Even a cursory look on corruption
in the past makes a horrible reading.
Government of a nation is repository of public confidence who contribute
their hard earned money for development of the country. Experience shows that
in India this trust has been hugely abused through unprecedented corruption and
complacency. After huge investments in building PSUs many have become
unproductive and making loss year after year. Reasons may be many like unsound
business plan, complacency at the level of personnel who do not act efficiently
and indulge in corruption. For example, profit making Air India was turned into
huge loss making enterprise, reason being personal gain and corruption by
people at the helm of affairs. Balance Sheet shall keep government
functionaries on their toes and not let the public money go waste.
·
The Balance Sheet is an automatic inducer to
growth. It silently enlivens human weakness of growth which in India is called "निन्याबे का फेर ". State and Central Governments shall be
automatically induced to increase Net Worth of the respective States and the
Nation.
·
Balance Sheet
shall invigorate the spirit of competitiveness amongst peer States. Similarly,
at national level Prime Minister of India shall be motivated to enhance Net
Worth of the Nation to overtake richer economies of America, China, Japan and
Britain.
·
Annual Balance Sheet shall provide invaluable
data and information to the Administrators and Planners for optimization of
return from all of the nation’s natural resources and assets, their safe
preservation for future generations, and their effective monitoring saving them
from willful abuse by cheaters and thugs.
·
Tab on Expenditure on unfinished
Projects
A big malaise in Government working has
been the tendency to declare a Project, spend some money to initiate it and
then put it on back burner. Such expenditure brings no advantage and results in
to waste of money spent on it. To give example of just one Ministry, while
presenting Railway budget for the year 2014-15 the new Railway Minister
disclosed and we quote-
“ 18. There has been focus on
sanctioning projects rather than completing them. In the last 30 years, as many
as 676 projects were sanctioned worth Rs 1,57,883 crore. Of these, only 317
projects could be completed and 359 projects remain to be completed which will
now require as much as Rs 1,82,000 crore.
“19. In the last 10 years, 99 New Line
projects worth Rs. 60,000 crore were sanctioned out of which only one project
is complete till date. In fact, there are 4 projects that are as old as 30
years, but are still not complete for one reason or another. The more projects
we add, the thinner we spread our resources and longer it takes to complete them.
…”
Source – Budget Speech Railway Minister
One can imagine if such is the state of
one Ministry then what could be the total quantum of unfinished Projects by all
State and Central Government Ministries. In absence of a Balance Sheet
the country does not know how big is the quantum of expenditure incurred on
unfinished projects in all State and Central Government Ministries. In Balance
Sheet expenditure on unfinished projects shall be reflected prominently. In
the Balance Sheet the expenditure incurred on a project that has not been
completed is shown under the head “Work in Progress”. So, with annual publication of National
Balance Sheet Government would be accountable for unfinished Projects.
·
The Balance Sheet would show value of total
Natural Resources and Assets at the disposal of the State and Central
Government. Annual income from these assets would show whether the revenue from
them is commensurate or it is being frittered away. For example, in the Annual
Budget for FY 2018-19 projected income from National Assets, termed “Non-tax
Revenue” is a meager Rs.2.45 Lakh Crore. In absence of total value of Assets we
do not know it is how much percent of the assets. As an illustration (crude at
that), if we value land at a flat rate
of just Rs. 100/- per sq meter, which is the cost of ordinary cloth, cost of
32.86 lakh sq Km of land area of the country would amount to Rs. 328.60 Lakh
Crore. Therefore, the total income of Rs.2.45 Lakh crore from all national
assets would be just 0.75% of our land asset only. Valuation of national assets and resources
would provoke thought process as to how to maximize revenue from them.
·
Helpful Financial Ratios - In the
business world, there are several helpful ratios that people use to determine a
company's long-term profitability and short-term financial outlook. These
numbers are of particular interest to those concerned about the credit or
sustainability of the company and to anyone considering purchasing the company
or shares of it. These ratios include the current ratio and the acid test or
liquidity ratio, and they are calculated using information from the Balance
Sheet.
·
Investors and Loans - Balance
Sheet is an ever-changing document which constantly writes in new
assets Enterprise acquires or new liabilities that the Enterprise undertakes.
When updated annually, the Balance Sheet will give potential lenders and
investors the information they need to make informed decisions about lending
money or other resources. Balance Sheet shows the assets, liabilities and net
worth, and when compared to earlier versions, current Balance Sheet even
reflects country’s ability to collect and pay debts over time. This is extremely
important to investors as the Balance Sheet indicates whether or not the
country will be able to pay investors back.
·
Priorities Outline -The
Balance Sheet gives an organized view
of current liabilities, including
short-term debt in the form of accounts
payable, which is inventory or services purchased from other businesses, and
the accrued expenses, which are items, such as wages to employees or taxes,
that will soon become due. The Balance Sheet also outlines long-term debt, such
as loans. The authorities can compare these figures and accounts to the assets
owned, such as cash, land, prepaid accounts, inventory, equipment and accounts
receivable, which are the goods or services
provided to customers that still need to be paid for. Looking at these
items can help Authorities determine which liabilities are a priority to take
care of and which assets can be adjusted or disposed of to help the country's
cash flow.
·
Last but not the least, annual accounting and
certification of national resources and assets by the concerned Officer In
charge shall safeguard them and deter theft, encroachment, illegal possession
or disposal at lower price, etc.
Once the country
starts making annual Balance Sheet it would be a nightmare to think how the
country was administered in the years gone by!!!
Text is available under the
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By
using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
Your last sentence in the article above contains the reason why governments do not produce balance sheets. I don't know how much exposure you have with IAS. Seems to be nil or negligible.
ReplyDeleteBut I highly appreciate your pains takingly written article.
Dr. Saaie
A great thanks Dr Saaie sir. I know it is a mission Impossible but I am fighting a no loss war. I am a retired person and doing it is giving me lots of insight in to things that can be achieved. Why blame IAS lobby only no politician will touch it. Lord Krishna says keep on doing your duty, leave result to me. May be good souls like you can one day make a difference. Thanks a lot sir again.
Delete